How Do You Make Natural Soap with Non-Toxic Ingredients?

Natural doesn’t mean chemical-free—and that’s okay. Let’s clear the confusion and make real, safe soap with non-toxic ingredients.

To make natural soap, mix organic oils with lye through a chemical reaction called saponification. While lye is necessary, it disappears after curing, leaving a gentle, non-toxic bar.

You don’t have to fear chemicals when you understand them. Soap is a chemical. But that doesn’t mean it’s harmful.

I’ll walk you through how to make natural soap that’s actually safe—no greenwashing, no fluff. Just real, skin-friendly science in a bar.

What Does “Natural Soap Without Chemicals” Really Mean?

“Chemical-free” soap is a myth. But non-toxic soap? That’s real.

All soap is made through saponification—a chemical reaction between oils and lye. True natural soap uses safe, plant-based oils and skips synthetic additives¹.

Let’s get it straight. You need lye (sodium hydroxide) to make soap. Without it, you don’t have soap—you have detergent or melt-and-pour base (which already had lye used).

The real goal is to make soap that avoids synthetic preservatives, fragrances, and detergents. Natural soap relies on cold process saponification using oils like olive or coconut, which fully react with lye and leave behind no caustic residue.

What you end up with is pure soap plus glycerin², which helps retain moisture.

Why Choose Non-Toxic Homemade Soap?

Making your own soap is safer than trusting confusing labels.

Non-toxic homemade soap avoids ingredients like parabens and triclosan³, costs less than store-bought organic bars, and reduces waste with biodegradable packaging.

I started making my own soap because I got tired of guessing what was in commercial brands. Parabens, sulfates, artificial fragrance—no thanks.

When you make soap yourself, you know exactly what’s going in. You also save money. A single bar costs me $1.50 to make. Store-bought versions? $7 or more.

Plus, I can wrap mine in cloth or paper instead of plastic. It’s better for my skin, my wallet, and the planet.

Essential Ingredients for Natural Soap?

Confused at the soap aisle? You only need a few basics.

To make natural soap, use organic plant oils (like olive and coconut), sodium hydroxide (lye), distilled water, and optional natural additives⁴ like essential oils or herbs.

Here’s a sample recipe I love:

Ingredient	Amount	Purpose
Olive oil	500 g	Base oil for gentleness
Coconut oil	100 g	Lather and cleansing power
Shea butter	50 g	Moisture and skin softening
Distilled water	152 g	Mix with lye
Sodium hydroxide	64 g	Required for saponification
Lavender EO	10–15 drops	Natural scent
Oatmeal (optional)	1 tbsp	Gentle exfoliant

All oils should be measured by weight. Use a digital scale. Always add lye to water—never the other way around.

Step-by-Step Cold Process Soap Recipe?

Think it’s complicated? It’s easier than baking bread.

Measure oils and lye, mix carefully, blend until thick, pour into molds, then cure for 4–6 weeks. Use pH strips⁵ to ensure it’s skin-safe.

Here’s how I make it:

1. Wear gloves, goggles, long sleeves. Ventilate your space.
2. Measure oils with a scale. Melt solids if needed.
3. Add lye into water—stir gently until dissolved. Let both cool to 110–115°F.
4. Combine oils and lye solution. Blend with a stick blender until thick like pudding (called “trace”).
5. Add essential oils, oats, or other extras.
6. Pour into silicone molds. Cover and insulate.
7. After 24–48 hours, unmold.
8. Let cure on a rack in a dry room for 4–6 weeks.
9. Test pH (ideal range is 7–10). Then, use or gift away.

Safety Tips for Handling Lye?

Lye isn’t scary if you respect it.

Wear protection, always add lye to water, and measure with a digital scale. Avoid aluminum containers⁶ and keep kids and pets away.

I used to be nervous about lye. But now I know—it’s just about safety. I wear gloves, goggles, and work near an open window.

I use a glass container to mix and always add lye to water slowly. Never use aluminum—it reacts. Always use a lye calculator to avoid adding too much. And store lye safely, far from food or kids.

Customizing Your Soap with Natural Additives?

Want pink soap that soothes eczema? Totally possible.

Add natural extras like shea butter, lavender oil, turmeric, or oats⁷ for added benefits and personal flair.

I love making soap that smells like a lavender field or looks like sunshine with turmeric. Here are a few customizations I use:

• Colorants: Turmeric (yellow), beetroot (pink), spirulina (green)
• Scents: Lavender, peppermint, or chamomile essential oils (5–15 drops per 500 g oil)
• Exfoliants: Oats, coffee grounds, or crushed herbs
• Soothing agents: Aloe vera, calendula, shea butter

For sensitive skin, avoid citrus oils and keep extras gentle.

Eco-Friendly Practices in Soap Making?

Soap making can be clean—for your skin and the Earth.

Use biodegradable oils, paper packaging, and reusable molds. Avoid synthetic surfactants⁸ like SLS or artificial fragrances.

When I started, I didn’t realize how wasteful some soap brands are. Plastic wrappers, palm oil from deforested regions, dyes that pollute water.

Now I choose organic, fair-trade oils and wrap soaps in upcycled cloth. I reuse molds and avoid anything artificial. Natural soap doesn’t just help your skin—it supports a healthier planet.

Common Mistakes to Avoid in Soap Making?

Small errors can make harsh soap. Here’s what to skip.

Don’t eyeball measurements, skip safety gear, or cure too little. Avoid using more than 30% coconut oil—it dries skin.

Here are mistakes I’ve made (so you don’t have to):

• Too much coconut oil = dry, harsh bars
• Not measuring lye = soap that burns
• Skipping cure = soft soap that doesn’t last
• No pH test = unsafe soap
• Wrong containers (like aluminum) = chemical reaction

Soap making is simple—but precise.

Conclusion

Natural, non-toxic soap starts with understanding—and ends with better skin and a cleaner world.

FAQ

Can you make soap without lye?
No. All real soap needs lye. But melt-and-pour soap has already gone through saponification.

Is homemade soap chemical-free?
No, but it’s non-toxic. Soap is a chemical salt made from natural ingredients.

How long does it take to make?
Around 1 hour to mix, 1–2 days to set, 4–6 weeks to cure.

What if I have sensitive skin?
Use mostly olive oil and avoid citrus or strong essential oils.

Cold process vs. melt-and-pour?
Cold process gives full control. Melt-and-pour skips lye handling but limits customization.

Footnotes: